Major Win for Bodies Corporate: Direct Right to Pursue Builders Confirmed
QLD
When water leaks or defects appear in a new building, one of the first questions lot owners ask is whether their body corporate can take action against the builder—especially when the body corporate wasn’t a party to the original construction contract. For years in Queensland, bodies corporate have sued builders directly, but there has always been uncertainty about whether this was technically allowed. That uncertainty has now been resolved.
In the case of Body Corporate for Westmark Milton CTS 49024 v Devine Constructions Pty Ltd [2026] QSC 9 (27 January 2026), the Supreme Court of Queensland delivered a clear and significant answer. A body corporate can bring contractual claims in its own name. It does not need to include the original developer, even if the developer has no interest in the case or no longer exists. This is an important clarification for bodies corporate, managers and the entire strata sector.
Who can take action when defects appear in a new building?
The Westmark Milton development was constructed under a 2014 contract between the developer, Walker and Devine Constructions. When the scheme was established in 2016, the body corporate came into existence.
In 2017, after a significant rain event, water leaked into 53 lots. Westmark alleged defects in the common property and commenced legal proceedings against Devine in 2023. Because it wasn’t a party to the original building contract, it relied on section 36(3) of the BCCM Act, which says the body corporate becomes “subrogated to the rights of the original owner” under any pre‑establishment contract relating to common property.
Devine argued that the body corporate had to sue the builder in the name of the developer or include the developer as a party in the case.
Westmark disagreed. It asked the Court to confirm that the body corporate could bring the claim in its own name, without needing the developer involved.
Did the body corporate need the developer to sue the builder?
Devine (the builder) argued “subrogation” is a technical legal concept. Under that concept, a subrogated party (the body corporate) must sue in the name of the original claimant (the developer). Therefore, Westmark had to include the developer.
Westmark (the body corporate) argued that the BCCM Act is designed to give bodies corporate practical control over common property. The word “subrogated” in this context was meant to operate as a statutory transfer of rights, not a technical limitation. Requiring the developer to be a party to a case would undermine the BCCM Act’s purpose and cause unnecessary cost and delay.
What the court decided about the body corporate’s right to sue
Justice Ryan agreed with Westmark.
The Court held that, in this context, “subrogated” was not used in its technical legal sense. Instead, section 36(3) of the BCCM Act transfers the original owner’s contractual rights to the body corporate. The body corporate can enforce those rights in its own name.
There is no requirement to include the developer, even if the developer has no ongoing role or has ceased to exist.
The Court granted Westmark the declaration it sought and dismissed Devine’s summary judgment application.
Why this decision matters for bodies corporate and managers
- Developers are often dissolved, disinterested or hard to locate. This decision removes the obstacle of including them in building defect cases if they are not required.
- Bodies corporate have long brought defect claims as the plaintiff in their own name, and this decision confirms that they are legally entitled to do so.
- This decision reduces cost, delay and procedural complexity for bodies corporate pursuing defect claims.
Body corporate managers frequently support committees with building defect claims. This decision provides clarity by confirming that a body corporate does have the legal right (“standing”) to bring such claims in its own name, reducing the risk of disputes about whether the committee is entitled to take action.
Summary
The Westmark Milton decision confirms that a body corporate can take a builder to court directly in its own name for defects affecting common property, even if the body corporate wasn’t part of the original construction contract and even if the developer has since disappeared. By concluding that the concept of subrogation and the phrase “subrogated to” is used in the context of section 36(3) of the BCCM Act as transferring the rights of the original owner to the body corporate, the Court has removed a major source of uncertainty. Bodies corporate, committees and managers can now pursue defect claims with greater confidence, fewer procedural hurdles and without the cost or delay of involving a developer who has no ongoing role.
Written by Peter Waller, Special Counsel, Grace Lawyers, QLD
If you’ve discovered defects in your building and need guidance on bringing a claim, our QLD team can help. Call us on 1300 144 436 for clear, practical legal advice.
