Tag Archive for: governance disputes

Fair Work Commission: AI-Generated Correspondence Can Make Body Corporate Disputes Worse

NATIONAL

Artificial Intelligence can draft a detailed letter in seconds, but does that make it effective? On 30 July 2026, the Fair Work Commission decided a dispute involving a body corporate committee and caretaker and delivered a timely warning about the risks of using AI to prepare correspondence in a dispute. The decision, together with recent body corporate adjudications involving costs orders, highlights how AI-generated communications can escalate conflict, obscure legitimate concerns, and hinder effective dispute resolution.

How can AI-generated emails affect a body corporate committee dispute?

The decision concerned the Sanctuary at Buderim CTS 40659 in Queensland. Mrs Deidre de Bruyn was a representative of the caretaker and had been involved in a long-running dispute with the body corporate committee concerning the scope of the caretaker’s duties and related matters. The contractual dispute had also been referred to the Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management.

In De Bruyn AB2025/973, Commissioner McKinnon made a specific observation about correspondence sent by Mr de Bruyn, another representative of the caretaker, to the body corporate. The Commissioner stated:

“It is also necessary to make a general observation about the correspondence sent to Sanctuary by Mr de Bruyn. In my view, the correspondence was unhelpful. It appears to have been prepared with the use of an artificial intelligence tool. It is lengthy, wide-ranging, replete with generalisations, repetitive, and often couched in accusatory language. It is unsurprising that the Sanctuary Committee eventually chose not to engage with Mr de Bruyn in response.”

The observation is striking because the Commission did not simply criticise the use of AI as a matter of style. Rather, the problem was the effect the correspondence had on the dispute. The correspondence was considered so lengthy and repetitive, and so broadly and aggressively expressed, that the committee eventually chose not to engage with it. Importantly, the Commission found that this was ultimately detrimental to everyone involved because some of the concerns being raised were reasonable and ought to have been acknowledged and addressed.

What are the risks of AI-generated correspondence?

When an owner or committee member is involved in a dispute, there can be a temptation to prepare a comprehensive letter setting out every complaint, historical grievance and perceived inconsistency. AI makes it particularly easy to produce such a document. A short list of issues can quickly become many pages of polished prose. But length does not necessarily make correspondence more persuasive.

In a body corporate dispute, the recipient needs to be able to identify what the actual issue is, what is being requested and what response is required. If those points are buried beneath pages of background material, repetition and allegations, the correspondence may become counterproductive.

The Commissioner’s concern was not that every proposition made by Mr de Bruyn was wrong. To the contrary, the Commissioner expressly recognised that some of the concerns were reasonable and should have been addressed. The difficulty was that the manner in which those concerns were communicated contributed to the breakdown in communication.

Another risk of AI-generated correspondence is that it can produce language that sounds formal, comprehensive and confident. That can give the writer the impression that the document is persuasive simply because it is professionally worded. However, effective dispute correspondence requires judgment, not merely polished language.

AI can also encourage generalisation. Instead of dealing with a particular committee resolution or particular incident, correspondence may describe a broader pattern of “ongoing unreasonable conduct”, “systemic failures” or “persistent breaches”. Such language may obscure rather than clarify the actual dispute.

Why did the commission ban the use of AI in future correspondence between the parties?

The significance of the Decision is reinforced by the separate Order made by Commissioner McKinnon. Paragraph 1 of the Order provides that future communication between the parties is to be accurate and respectful, and expressly prohibits the use of artificial intelligence tools in preparing correspondence between the parties.

That is an unusually direct instruction.

The lesson for body corporate disputes is not necessarily that AI can never be used for any purpose. Rather, where parties are in a contentious relationship, correspondence needs to be carefully considered and genuinely responsive.

Body corporate disputes require particularly careful communication

Queensland body corporate disputes often involve multiple participants. A committee may comprise several owners. There may also be a body corporate manager, caretaker, letting agent, contractors and individual lot owners. Correspondence can subsequently become part of a committee record, an adjudication application, court proceedings or another formal process.

The Decision provides examples of how poor communication can compound an existing dispute. The Commission found, among other things, that certain information circulated to owners was inaccurate or incomplete, and that some concerns raised by Ms de Bruyn were not properly addressed. The Commission also identified failures to provide meaningful responses to certain complaints and concerns.

These examples demonstrate that there are two separate communication failures that can occur in a dispute: sending correspondence that is too extensive to be useful, and failing to respond meaningfully to correspondence that raises legitimate issues. Both can make resolution harder.

How can written communication be used more effectively?

Before sending correspondence, identify the precise issue. State the relevant facts briefly. Identify the decision, conduct or event that is disputed. Explain the evidence relied upon. State what outcome is sought. If a response is required, ask a clear question and provide a reasonable timeframe.

For example, instead of sending a lengthy letter alleging a committee has repeatedly acted improperly, an owner might identify three specific committee decisions, explain why each is disputed, attach the relevant documents and ask the committee to reconsider each decision.

Similarly, a committee responding to an owner should address the actual questions raised rather than responding with a general rejection of the owner’s position.

Summary

The De Bruyn decision is a further useful warning for anyone involved in a Queensland body corporate dispute. The Fair Work Commission highlight the risks of overreliance on AI-generated correspondence in body corporate disputes. Even where concerns are legitimate, lengthy and accusatory communications can undermine effective engagement.

 

If you are involved in a dispute involving excessive AI-generated correspondence, contact our team on 1300 144 436 for guidance.

 

Written by Brendan Pitman, Partner, Grace Lawyers QLD

 

Last updated on 26 August 2026

VCAT Confirms Pre-Voting at Owners Corporation AGMs Is Not Lawful

VIC

It has been common practice for some owners corporations and their managers to encourage lot owners to cast their votes before an annual general meeting using dedicated voting software. This practice, known as ‘pre-voting’, has now been addressed by VCAT in Proequity Pty Ltd v Owners Corporation [2026] VCAT 858.

The decision of Vice President Judge Tran confirms that pre-voting is not a legislatively authorised method of voting at an annual general meeting. Owners corporations and their managers should therefore review their voting procedures to ensure they comply with the Owners Corporations Act 2006 (Vic) (OCA) and the Owners Corporations Regulations 2018 (Vic) (OCR).

The Rise of Pre-Voting in Owners Corporations

Pre-voting occurs when a lot owner submits a vote before a meeting, without attending the meeting or appointing a proxy to vote on their behalf.

This practice has often been facilitated through voting software, with instructions provided in the notice of meeting. It has been particularly convenient for lot owners who are unable to attend a meeting but nevertheless wish to participate in decision-making.

However, convenience does not establish that a voting method is legally valid. The OCA and OCR prescribe how lot owners may participate in meetings and how votes may be cast.

What the Legislation actually permits

Neither the OCA nor the OCR provides a mechanism for a lot owner to cast a vote before a meeting, independently of the meeting and without appointing a proxy.

The relevant provisions are:

  • Section 80 of the OCA: A lot owner may participate in a meeting by teleconference, by proxy or in another manner prescribed by the OCR.
  • Regulation 7A of the OCR: Participation in a meeting by teleconference may be by way of video conference facilities.
  • Section 89(1) of the OCA: A vote on a resolution may be taken at a meeting by a show of hands or in another prescribed manner.
  • Section 89(3) of the OCA: A lot owner may call for a poll at a meeting, in which case voting must be conducted by written vote.
  • Section 89(6) of the OCA: A person who participates in a meeting by teleconference or another prescribed manner is taken to be present in person at the meeting.
  • Regulation 7B of the OCR: This provision is headed ‘voting on a resolution of the owners corporation at a meeting”.

Read together, the above provisions contemplate participation and voting through the methods authorised by the legislation at a meeting. They do not authorise lot owners to submit votes independently before the meeting.

If a lot owner cannot attend a meeting, they can participate by appointing a proxy, but submitting a vote in advance is not a substitute for doing so.

The VCAT decision: Proequity Pty Ltd v Owners Corporation [2026] VCAT 858

The decision in Proequity concerned the validity of votes relating to the election of a committee at an annual general meeting.

The notice of annual general meeting stated that pre-voting would close one hour before the meeting commenced. It encouraged lot owners who were unable to attend but wished to vote to complete and submit their votes in advance. The voting arrangements were also accompanied by inconsistent instructions and explanations about how lot owners could cast their votes.

Judge Tran confirmed that pre-voting is not a legislatively authorised method of voting at an annual general meeting.[1] Her Honour further explained that a lot owner who cannot attend the meeting may vote by authorising a proxy to vote on their behalf.[2]

A key issue was the owners corporation’s acceptance of voting papers submitted as pre-votes. Her Honour identified this as an incorrect decision by the owners corporation.[3] The decision also highlighted the responsibility of the proposed committee, which had taken it upon itself to create an unauthorised (and invalid) voting paper and encourage other lot owners to use it.[4]

The decision is a timely reminder that owners corporations, committees and managers cannot introduce alternative voting procedures simply because they are convenient or have become established practice. Voting arrangements must be consistent with the statutory framework.

Why does it matter? The risks of relying on pre-voting

The issue is not merely procedural. Where an owners corporation accepts pre-votes and relies on them in determining the outcome of a resolution, there may be a risk that the validity of the resolution itself is challenged.

That risk may be particularly significant where:

  • the resolution passes by a narrow margin;
  • pre-votes affect the result of an election for committee positions;
  • special resolutions are involved; or
  • there is already disagreement amongst lot owners about the governance of the owners corporation.

Voting procedures exist to ensure that all lot owners participate on an equal footing and in accordance with the statutory framework. Departing from those procedures may create uncertainty about whether resolutions have been validly passed and can lead to disputes, applications to VCAT and additional costs for the owners corporation.

Following Proequity, owners corporations and managers should carefully consider whether any historical reliance on pre-voting could expose future decisions to challenge.

Implications for owners corporations and managers

Following Proequity, owners corporations and their managers should review their meeting notices, voting procedures and use of voting software.

Key takeaways:

  • Stop accepting pre-votes: Lot owners should not be invited to submit votes before a meeting as an alternative to participating in the meeting or appointing a proxy.
  • Direct absent lot owners to appoint a proxy: Where a lot owner cannot attend, they should be provided with clear instructions about appointing a proxy in accordance with the OCA and the prescribed form ↗
  • Review voting software and meeting notices: Any software, forms or instructions that facilitate pre-voting should be reviewed and amended to ensure that voting practices are lawful.
  • Exercise care when developing voting procedures: Committees and managers should not create or implement their own voting methods without first confirming that those methods are authorised by the legislation.

There may also be broader consequences where a committee member deliberately adopts an unauthorised voting procedure to advance their own interests. Depending on the circumstances, such conduct may raise questions of good faith and the availability of the immunity under section 118 of the OCA. However, the application of that provision will depend on the particular facts and legal issues involved.

Summary

Proequity confirms that pre-voting is not an authorised method of voting at an annual general meeting. Owners corporations and their managers should ensure that lot owners are given clear options for participating in meetings, including appointing a proxy where they cannot attend.

Established practice and administrative convenience are not substitutes for statutory authority. Reviewing voting procedures can help owners corporations avoid disputes about the validity of resolutions.

 

If you believe pre-votes may have affected the outcome of a closely contested committee election or resolution, contact our VIC Strata and Property team on 1300 144 436 for guidance on any associated compliance risks.

 

Prepared by Leila Idris, Partner, and Katrina Lay, Associate, Grace Lawyers

References

[1] Proequity Pty Ltd v Owners Corporation [2026] VCAT 858 at [67].

[2] Ibid at [70].

[3] Ibid at [79].

[4] Ibid at [80].

 

Last updated on 29 October 2026