Tag Archive for: common property

RECOVERING COSTS FROM AN OWNER WHO FAILS TO MAINTAIN THEIR LOT IN GOOD CONDITION

Some features of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) (BCCM Act) that have stood the test of time are the “self-help” remedies to deal with common problems that arise when large numbers of people live together in a dense environment.

It may seem pessimistic, but the drafters of this legislation did not expect people to do the right thing all the time.  They expected people to be fallible and, for example, to allow their property to fall into a state of disrepair.  When that happened, the drafters put in clear and cost-effective remedies to allow a body corporate to “get the job done” ultimately at the owner’s expense or for those who suffered damage from a neighbour’s neglect to receive compensation without having to join the long line of litigants in front of Queensland’s Courts.

These provisions complimented the stated objectives of the BCCM Act of promoting self-management and establishing an effective dispute resolution process.  If you would like to know how you can make a fallible neighbour accountable for the poor condition or their lot or the property damage they have caused, please read on.

There are two key remedies we will explore:

  1. Bodies corporate were given the power to stop the problem at its source by entering a lot, performing work that is required of an owner and then recovering the reasonable costs of the repair works as a debt.
  2. Bodies corporate and owners / occupiers who suffer property damage because of the fault of a neighbour were then given the ability to ask an adjudicator to order compensation or for repairs to be carried out.

The power to enter and perform work in the lot

 A lot owner must maintain their lot in good condition and an occupier must keep parts of the lot readily observable from another lot or the common property in a clean and tidy condition.[1]  If an owner or occupier does not carry out work required to maintain the lot in good condition, then the body corporate is empowered carry out the work and may recover the reasonable costs from the owner as a debt.

For example, if the tray of a shower in a lot begins to leak and the owner fails to repair it, then the body corporate may step in to carry out that work.

You will see that this power also applies to work required of an occupier (to keep the external appearance of a lot clean and tidy), but it allows the body corporate to recover the costs of the cleaning work from the owner (even if they are different people).

Why would the legislation allow the body corporate to hold an owner accountable for the sins of the tenant?  In my view, it is because this makes the costs a body corporate debt[2], which offers significant advantages to the body corporate.

A liability to pay a body corporate debt is enforceable against a person (including a mortgagee in possession) who becomes an owner of the lot before the debt is paid.  So in practice, a patient body corporate does not need to take recovery action in a court or tribunal for these costs – it could simply wait until the current owner wants to sell.[3]  The buyer will make sure the costs are paid at settlement so they do not inherit liability for that debt.

An owner held liable for the sins of the tenant in this way should in turn look to recover those costs from the occupier under the tenancy agreement.

The costs recovered by the body corporate must be “reasonable”.  To reduce the room for argument on this point, the body corporate should source at least two quotations from third parties who are appropriately qualified or licenced to perform the work.

The body corporate is empowered[4] to authorise a person to enter and remain on a lot while it is reasonably necessary to:

  • inspect the lot and find out whether work the body corporate is authorised or required to carry out is necessary; or
  • carry out work the body corporate is authorised or required to carry out.

Even though the body corporate is not required to carry out work required of an owner or occupier, the regulation module authorises it to carry out this work.  That is why the power of entry applies.

This is an invasive power.  It allows persons unknown to an occupier to enter their home.  There are rules that must be strictly followed when exercising that power:

  • at least seven days’ notice must be given to the occupier – this notice period can only be shortened or dispensed with in an emergency; and
  • entry must be in compliance with the security or other arrangement or requirements ordinarily apply to persons entering the lot.

Repairs or compensation for damage caused

 A significant feature of the BCCM Act is the dispute resolution process established under chapter 6.  It built upon the role of referees resolving disputes that arose under the BCCM Act’s predecessor, the Building Units and Group Titles Act 1980 (Qld) (BUGTA), and expanded that system to include an information service, departmental conciliation and adjudications.

A helpful improvement introduced in the BCCM Act is that it empowered adjudicators to give remedies to those who had suffered property damage caused by someone else’s contravention.

If the adjudicator is satisfied that the applicant[5] has suffered damage to property because of a contravention of the BCCM Act or the scheme’s community management statement, the adjudicator may order the person response for the contravention to:

  • carry out repairs, or have repairs carried out, to the damaged property – the repairs cannot cost more than $75,000; or
  • pay the applicant up to $10,000 as reimbursement for repairs already carried out by the applicant.[6]

If the repairs are likely to cost more than $75,000 or the applicant wants to pursue compensation of more than $10,000, then the legal action must be brought in a court of competent jurisdiction so long as a certificate of dismissal is obtained.[7]

This provides a limited remedy where, for example, an owner fails to maintain their lot in good condition, and it causes damage to another lot or the common property that needs to be repaired.  It is also of assistance if an owner or occupier suffers property damage because a body corporate failed to maintain common property in good condition or contravened a provision of the BCCM Act.

The remedy is limited to repairs to damaged property.  The aggrieved party may have suffered other types of damages (ie loss of rent if their unit was wholly or partially uninhabitable because of the damage), but adjudicators do not have the power to order compensation for other types of damages.[8]

Putting it all together

To put all of that into practice:

  • the body corporate may discover water ingress from an internal part of the building that is affecting another lot or common property;
  • if there are reasonable grounds to suspect that the water leak is coming from another lot – for example, a qualified or licensed person inspecting damage gives their opinion as to the likely source/s of the leak – the body corporate may authorise a person to enter the lot to inspect whether it is necessary to carry out any work;
  • that first inspection may reveal that the water ingress is being caused by a shower tray having fallen into a state of disrepair;
  • ideally, the owner of that lot should be notified of the defect and given a reasonable opportunity to repair the shower tray;
  • if that opportunity is not taken up, the body corporate can authorise a person to enter the lot again the carry out the necessary repairs;
  • the body corporate may then recover from that owner the reasonable costs of the repairs to the damaged lot as a debt – this recovery action can be taken in a court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction;
  • if the common property has been damaged (a common property wall may be water stained or the carpet could be damaged from the leak), then the body corporate:
    • must first attempt to resolve the dispute internally, such as by writing to the owner to give notice of the damage and an opportunity to pay for the repairs or pay compensation for the repairs carried out to the water-stained wall / damaged carpet; and
    • may, if the dispute is not resolved internally, apply to an adjudicator for an order that the repairs be carried out at the expense of the owner at a cost of up to $75,000 or for compensation of up to $10,000; and
  • if another lot has been damaged, then the owner or occupier of that lot:
    • must similarly attempt to resolve the dispute internally; and
    • may, if the dispute is not resolved internally, apply to an adjudicator for an order that the repairs be carried out at the expense of the owner at a cost of up to $75,000 or for compensation of up to $10,000.

This information is intended to provide a general summary only and should not be relied on as a substitute for legal advice.

[1] Section 170 of the Body Corporate and Community Management (Standard Module) Regulation 2008 (Qld) (SM 2008).  When the new regulation modules commence on 1 March 2021, this reference will be section 211 of the Body Corporate and Community Management (Standard Module) 2020 (Qld) (SM 2020).  There are mirror provisions in the Accommodation Module, but only the Standard Module will be referenced in this article.

[2] The definition of “body corporate debt” includes an amount associated with the ownership of a lot that is owed by an owner of a lot to the body corporate.

[3] However, a limitation period of six years will apply, so there must be a limit to the body corporate’s patience.

[4] Section 163 of the BCCM Act.

[5] The applicant could be a body corporate, an owner or an occupier.

[6] Section 281 of the BCCM Act.

[7] Sections 250 and 270 of the BCCM Act.

[8] See Beatrice Gardens [2012] QBCCMCmr 383 at [9] and Top of the Mark [2014] QBCCMCmr 136 at [68].

Navigating Decision-Making Whilst Acting Reasonably

QLD

In Queensland, Section 94(2) of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Act) imposes a mandatory obligation on a body corporate to act reasonably in performing its general functions and obligations under the Act. This obligation applies to any decision the body corporate makes or chooses not to make.

The concept of reasonableness has proven to be problematic for bodies corporate in the application of the obligation in its daily decision-making and more often than not results in adjudication proceedings in a wide variety of body corporate matters.

If an adjudicator is satisfied that a body corporate decision was unreasonably made the adjudicator may overturn and override the decision.

What is Reasonable?

In Ainsworth v Albrecht [2016] HCA 40 the High Court considered and clarified the concept of reasonableness within the context of the opposition of a lot owner to a motion to be resolved by resolution without dissent. The High Court made the following observations in respect of reasonableness:

  • it does not equate to what an adjudicator considers just and equitable
  • it does not involve the application of discretionary considerations
  • it is objective
  • it has to be applied at the time of the decision, taking into account the relevant factors

Recent Adjudication Decisions

In two recent cases, the matters of Monaco Apartments [2024] QBCCMCmr 284 and Everton Mews [2024] QBCCMCmr the adjudicator was required to consider whether the body corporate acted reasonably.

Monaco Apartments Case

The case of Monaco Apartments involved the body corporate committee refusing to allow a lot owner approval to install a blind on his balcony. The body corporate refused consent on the basis that the blind would be visible from the outside and would detract from the appearance of the scheme.

Whereas the matter was ultimately determined on other grounds, the adjudicator made the following observations:

“What is reasonable is a question of fact, to be determined by objectively considering all relevant factors (and ignoring irrelevant ones). Reasonable decision-making involves taking a rational, logical and evidence-based approach in reaching a conclusion.”

The adjudicator held that whereas it would not be unreasonable to consider the visual appearance of the scheme, it has to be considered with reference to effect of the specific improvement in question and the effect it would have on the appearance of the building.

Everton Mews Case

The case of Everton Mews involved the body corporate refusing to allow a lot owner to install whirlybirds on her roof, which was common property. The body corporate refused consent on the basis of its view that whirlybirds were an inefficient form of ventilation that may cause a likelihood of water ingress and a post installation maintenance burden. The committee proposed that the owner consider more viable and effective devices such as ceiling fans or air conditioning within her lot before making structural changes to the common property.

The adjudicator was required to consider whether the body corporate failed to act reasonably when it did not approve the lot owner’s request for approval of the installation of whirlybirds on her roof.

The adjudicator made the following observations regarding its role in the adjudication:

“When a committee’s decision-making is challenged, the role of the adjudicator is to evaluate whether the committee ignored or failed to genuinely consider any relevant factors, or whether it acted on irrelevant factors. The role of the adjudicator is not to weigh the factors nor substitute their own views or conclude that another decision would have been more reasonable.”

The adjudicator held that the body corporate failed to act reasonably when it refused to approve the lot owner’s request, amongst other things, on the following grounds:

  • when required to authorise an improvement to common property the body corporate should consider the interest of the person seeking approval as well as how the proposed improvement could affect the other owners or scheme property
  • the request must be decided with regards to the circumstances in the context of its particular scheme
  • genuine fact-based concerns should be considered with regards to whether they could be overcome through the imposition of appropriate conditions
  • the location, size, appearance, conditions of installation and ongoing maintenance were all relevant factors for consideration and which were addressed by the lot owner by the conditions proposed
  • the concerns with regards to potential water ingress were hypothetical and not evidence-based and adequately addressed by the conditions proposed
  • the merits of alternative ventilation options were not relevant because the lot owner was not seeking approval for those

Summary

At first blush the body corporate’s obligation to act reasonably appears to be very straightforward and simple, but that is not the case. A body corporate is required to comply with its obligation to act reasonably within the context and circumstances of its particular scheme and with regards to the subject of the particular matter before it. Each matter turns on its own facts and circumstances.

The body corporate’s failure to act reasonably in its decision-making would invariably give rise to a dispute, which in turn would take up time and money to resolve.

It is important that the body corporate understand the nature and extent of its obligation to act reasonably with a view to pursue compliance and avoid disputes and adjudication.

Written by Brendan Pitman, Partner, Grace Lawyers

 

At Grace we provide bodies corporate with effective, efficient and affordable advice to navigate this complicated obligation. If you need to manage the risk of being challenged in decision-making for acting unreasonably, call us on 1300 144 436.

 

Can a Lot Owner be Imprisoned for Feeding Birds?

QLD

Can a Lot owner be imprisoned for feeding birds? It seems like it would be a pretty straightforward answer of “No”.

However, we recently acted for a Body Corporate that obtained orders in the Magistrates Court of Queensland that in effect, stated if a Lot owner continued to feed the birds at the scheme he would be subject to imprisonment for a period of three months.

So How Did We and the Body Corporate Get to this Stage?

In 2018, the Body Corporate obtained orders from an Adjudicator of the Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management that stated:

“[the Owner] must immediately cease allowing food scraps to fall, be placed or thrown onto the common property in any way that encourages wild birds/animals to come onto the common property.”

There is nothing particularly unusual about those orders as they are often issued by Adjudicators for breaches of by-laws and the nuisance provisions under the Act.

What was unusual was the extent of the damage to the scheme and the effect that feeding birds had on other owners. The mess caused by the birds (and by mess, yes, I mean faeces) was so extensive that it required the Body Corporate to continually clean the common property and rendered the balcony below the owner’s lot to be unusable, as the mess posed a risk to public health and safety.

The story does not end there. The Lot owner continued to feed the birds in contravention of the Adjudicator’s Orders.

In 2019, the Body Corporate, through its solicitors at the time, registered the Adjudicator’s Order as an Order of the Magistrates Court to take enforcement steps. The form of that enforcement was to issue a Complaint and Summons in the Magistrates Court for failing to comply with the Adjudicator’s Orders.

This resulted in the Lot owner being fined $1,000 and having to make payment of some of the Body Corporate’s costs.

Still, the Lot owner was not deterred. He continued to feed the birds, and in 2020, the Lot owner was again issued with a Complaint and Summons, which resulted in him being fined $2,500 and being required to pay some of the Body Corporate’s costs.

Contempt of Court Proceedings

Despite being fined for a second time, the Lot owner continued his conduct. At this stage our firm was engaged to provide the Body Corporate with some further options.

The option provided to the Body Corporate, and ultimately pursued, was to bring an application for Contempt of Court which carries a potential prison sentence.

The Lot owner was served with the application for contempt but did not appear at the hearing of the application. Due to the very serious nature of the penalty that could be applied, the Magistrate issued a Warrant for the Arrest of the Lot owner to be brought before the Court for the hearing of the application.

That ultimately occurred earlier this month.

Result of Contempt of Court Proceedings

The Magistrate made orders that the Contempt of Court had been proven and that the Lot owner was to be sentenced to three months’ imprisonment, suspended for two years. The Body Corporate was awarded significant costs for this process.

The effect of the Order is that if the Lot owner feeds the birds again in the next two years he will, on the application of the Body Corporate, likely be sentenced to a term of three months’ imprisonment.

If we take a step back, a potential term of imprisonment on the surface seems to be a pretty extreme punishment.

However, the Magistrate’s and the Court’s punishment was not for the act of feeding birds, but rather the continued failure to comply with Orders made by an Adjudicator and the Magistrates Court over a period of approximately five years. The lesser punishments of fines did not deter the Lot owner, so the Magistrate was prepared to make the Orders for Contempt.

So, I return to my initial question, can a Lot owner be imprisoned for feeding birds?

The answer to that question is “No”, but they most definitely can be imprisoned for Contempt of Court.

Written by Brenton Schoch, Partner, Grace Lawyers

 

At Grace we provide bodies corporate with effective, efficient and affordable advice. Call us on 1300 144 436 for guidance if a Lot owner fails to comply with an Adjudicator’s Orders.

 

What About my Human Rights? Does Human Rights Legislation Apply to Strata?

QLD

In most modern democracies, the progression of the human rights movement over the last 75 years has led to increasing claims that one’s human rights have been violated.

In the aftermath of the Second World War, in 1948 the United Nations General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, outlining an individual’s inalienable rights and freedoms. This declaration formed the cornerstone of the subsequent growth and adoption of binding laws in participating nations, including Australia.

In the recent decision of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Tribunal) in Huang v Body Corporate for the Dorchester CTS 10749 [2024] QCATA 64 (Dorchester), the Tribunal examined the application of the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) (HR Act) to community titles schemes.

Background

The appellant, Mr Huang (Owner), was the owner of Lot 32 on the top-level of the scheme, which also had exclusive use over the rooftop area.

In or around 1998, the Owner constructed a toilet and shower facility on the rooftop (Improvement) without Body Corporate approval. On 29 June 2000, a resolution was made at general meeting granting retrospective approval for the Improvement.

Over 20 years later, at a general meeting held on 17 March 2022, the Body Corporate made a resolution rescinding authority for the Improvement (Resolution) in order to undertake waterproofing works to the rooftop area (Works). The Body Corporate formed the view that the Improvement required removal to properly complete the Works.

Commissioner’s Office1

In the proceedings below, the Owner sought to challenge the validity of the Resolution, including on the ground that the decision was unreasonable. On this ground, the main contention of the Owner was that the Improvement did not require removal for the Body Corporate to complete the Works (on the basis there was an alternative method of carrying out the necessary repairs without removing the Improvement).

The Adjudicator dismissed the application, determining that the Resolution was not unreasonable. The Adjudicator relied on the fact that the Body Corporate’s expert recommended that it was preferable for the Improvement to be removed (and not reinstated) in order to properly complete the Works and minimise the risk of water ingress into the building in future.

The QCAT appeal—an arbitrary deprivation of the Owner’s property rights?

The Owner appealed the Adjudicator’s decision to the Tribunal raising several grounds of appeal, including that the Adjudicator failed to construe the Body Corporate’s duty to act reasonably in a way compatible with his human rights under the HR Act.

The Owner sought to argue that both the Resolution, and the Adjudicator’s decision, contravened the HR Act – by arbitrarily depriving him of his property. The appellant contended that the Adjudicator was obliged to consider his human rights in making a decision.

In reaching a decision dismissing the appeal, the Tribunal found:

  • The Owner’s exclusive use rights, including the Improvements, were proprietary rights subject to the HR Act.
  • Critically, the object of the HR Act is to regulate and temper decision-making in the public sector, and the nature of an adjudication dispute was the resolution of a private dispute.
  • Accordingly, there was no obligation on the Body Corporate to consider the Owner’s human rights in making the Resolution, as the Body Corporate is a private entity (not subject to the HR Act).
  • Similarly, although the Adjudicator was acting as a public entity (ordinarily subject to the HR Act), he was not bound to apply the HR Act in reaching a decision (as he was not performing functions of a public nature and, instead, was acting in a judicial-type capacity to resolve a private dispute).

Another interesting outcome of the appeal was the Tribunal’s dismissal of the Owner’s claim that the Adjudicator failed to give sufficient weight to a report of the Owner’s expert that suggested the Works could be adequately undertaken without requiring removal of the Improvement.

On this ground the Tribunal held that, although the Owner’s expert had opined that the Work could proceed without removing the Improvement, the opinion was highly qualified. Even the Owner’s own expert acknowledged that completing the Work with the Improvement in place would be more tedious and costly, and the effectiveness of the results more uncertain. Accordingly, given the serious nature of water penetration into the building, it was not unreasonable for the Body Corporate to prefer the more rigorous approach to the repairs (involving removal of the Improvement).

Conclusion

The Tribunal has determined that the HR Act does not apply in the private setting, including in relation to both body corporate decision-making, as well as public decision-makers resolving private disputes (such as Adjudicators).

The decision in Dorchester should also serve as a reminder to owners who undertake improvements to areas of common property (including exclusive use areas) that, regardless of whether they have approval of the body corporate, it may not be unreasonable for the body corporate to subsequently rescind the approval (and compel removal of the improvements) in circumstances where it is necessary for the body corporate to carry out its statutory functions (including its duty to maintain the common property in good order and repair).

It is important to note that the decision in Dorchester (about the (non-) application of the HR Act to private community titles disputes) is different from the applicability of other legislative instruments concerning anti-discrimination.

Other state and federal laws (such as the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) and Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth)) do operate in the context of community titles schemes, including in relation to accessibility of common property and body corporate decision-making (as evidenced by the Tribunal’s decision in Knox v Body Corporate for 19th Avenue CTS 6625 [2020] QCAT 497).

That said, the operation of anti-discrimination legislation, and determination of whether there has been a contravention of same (as well as any penalty), carries a much narrower analysis and application than broad allegations and complaints from owners and occupiers that they have been discriminated against.

Similar to allegations of defamation, it is easy for someone to claim their ‘human rights’ have been infringed, or that they have been subject to discrimination. However, it is a very different thing to successfully prosecute such a claim.

Whilst those operating within community titles schemes should be aware of obligations under anti-discrimination laws (e.g. disability discrimination legislation), based on the decision in Dorchester, bodies corporate, committees, owners and occupiers can move forward with relative confidence that the Human Rights Act 2019 (Qld) is not applicable to private disputes in community titles schemes.

1. The Dorchester [2023] QBCCMCmr 220.

Written by Jarad Maher, Partner, Grace Lawyers

Victoria’s Workplace Manslaughter Laws – Important reminders for Owners Corporations

VIC

As of 1 July 2020, Victoria saw a new set of occupational health and safety laws come into effect by amendments to the Occupational Health & Safety Act 2004 (Vic) (OHS Act) by the Workplace Safety Legislation Amendments (Workplace Manslaughter and Other Matters) Bill 2019 (Vic). The new legislation applies to the negligent conduct of employers (or other duty holders) causing death to whom a duty of care is owed. The penalties under the new legislation are significant and include a maximum of 25 years imprisonment for individuals and a fine in excess of $19 million for body corporates.

The recent case of R v LH Holding Management Pty Ltd & Laith Hanna1 is the first case an employer was convicted under Victoria’s new workplace manslaughter laws. It underscores crucial lessons for owners corporations, particularly in overseeing tradesmen and suppliers working on strata schemes. Below is a summary of the key learnings and safety considerations.

Overview

On 19 February 2024, LH Holding Management Pty Ltd (LH Holding) and Laith Hanna (Hanna), the sole director and secretary of LH Holding, were sentenced by the Victorian Supreme Court following guilty pleas to the workplace manslaughter of Michael Tsahrelias (Tsahrelias). LH Holding was fined $1.3 million, and Hanna was sentenced to a two-year Community Correction Order (CCO), with conditions including that Hanna complete 200 hours of community work and undertake a forklift operation course. Additionally, LH Holding and Hanna, by consent, were ordered to pay $120,000 in compensation to Tsahrelias’s sister, in turn for Tsahrelias’s parents compensation claims being dismissed.

Background

LH Holding operated a stonemasonry factory under the direction of Hanna. Tsahrelias and his father, through their family business, were subcontracted by LH Holding to work at the factory.

On 12 October 2021, Hanna was operating a forklift to move an empty A-frame steel rack from inside the factory to an outside area. Upon manoeuvring the forklift, the 2-metre suspended load began to swing and Tsahrelias attempted to stabilise the load with his arms. Hanna, with Tsahrelias in close proximity, then began to reverse the forklift up the sloped driveway, however the forklift lost balance, began to tip sideways and toppled over, crushing Tsahrelias beneath it. The incident, captured by CCTV, revealed its severity and Hanna’s failure to ensure Tsahrelias’ safety.

Charges and sentencing

Following the incident, LH Holding was charged under section 39G(1) of the OHS Act for workplace manslaughter, and Hanna was charged under section 39G(2) as an officer whose failure to take reasonable care contributed to the manslaughter. Both Hanna and LH Holding pleaded guilty to the charges.

Hanna, in his interview with WorkSafe, acknowledged that he had failed to follow the safety protocols and that more caution should have been exercised given the elevated and irregular load and the sloped driveway. Ultimately, LH Holding and Hanna were found negligent for breaching their duty of care.

In sentencing, the court considered extensive submissions, including victim impact statements from Tsahrelias’ family, the guilty pleas, mitigating factors, deterrence and prospects of rehabilitation.

The court imposed the following sentences:

  • LH Holding was fined $1.3 million.
  • Hanna was sentenced to a two-year community detention order (CCO), with conditions to complete 200 hours of community work and a forklift operation course.
  • LH Holding and Hanna were ordered to pay $120,000 in compensation to Tsahrelias’ sister.

The sentences and penalties imposed on LH Holding and Hanna aim to serve as a deterrent and reinforce the need for strict compliance with occupational health and safety regulations to prevent future tragedies.

Key takeaways for owners corporations

The workplace manslaughter provisions under the OHS Act (Part 5A) are designed to prevent workplace deaths and impose severe penalties to reflect the seriousness of breaches leading to fatal incidents.

Although the OHS Act refers to the legislation applying to individuals and bodies corporate, the OHS Act extends to owners corporations (OC) as a legal entity. Accordingly, and in light of the new legislation, an OC ought to be remain mindful of the following:

  1. An OC has a duty of care to maintain the common property and to maintain a safe environment for anyone who enters or undertakes work.
  2. An OC’s duty of care is to all employees, contractors, owners, residents, visitors or general members of the public who enter common property.
  3. The new laws concern existing duties of an OC under the OHS Act, however their penalties are now more significant when a breach results in death.
  4. To reduce risk, the OC must be proactive at discharging its functions to repair and maintain common property and its duties to act in good faith and with due care and diligence in ensuring all safety protocols and measures are in place to avoid any catastrophic incidents.

An OC may manage occupational health and safety in several ways. For example:

  • Risk assessments: the OC may obtain a health and safety occupational report to assess the common property to identify potential hazards and prevent accidents.
  • Safety audits: if the OC has employees, it may engage WorkSafe to carry out an occupational health and safety audit on the common property.
  • Repair and maintenance: promptly attending to repair and maintenance of common property.
  • Communication: inform lot owners and occupations of any hazards and provide clear instructions to avoid danger.
  • Maintenance Plan: the OC reviews its maintenance plan and engages specialised professionals to inspect the common property to assist with risk assessment, maintenance fund forecast, capital works and budgeting. Even if there is no maintenance plan, an OC should review maintenance of works that are necessary, the cost and timing for the maintenance work.

Summary

The tragic case of Tsahrelias highlights the severe consequences of failing to maintain workplace safety and serves as a stark reminder to OCs of the critical importance of safety in managing tradesmen and suppliers within strata schemes. OC managers must actively engage in creating and maintaining a safe working environment, ensuring all safety measures are in place and that legal requirements are met. Through ensuring all safety protocols are followed, an OC can prevent such incidents, safeguard lives and avoid severe legal and financial repercussions.

1. R v LH Holding Management Pty Ltd & Hanna [2024] VSC 90. [2024] VSC 90.

 

Written by Leila Idris, Partner and Eleni Tasiopoulos, Lawyer, Grace Lawyers

If you require advice regarding workplace safety or managing tradesmen and suppliers within your strata scheme, please contact our Victorian team on 1300 144 436.

Exclusive Use Maintenance – ‘But the Owner Built It!’

QLD

A recent adjudication decision has clarified a seemingly unchartered issue about maintenance responsibility in exclusive use areas – and the outcome may surprise you.

Background

In the matter of Jefferson Villas [2024] QBCCMCmr 473 (Jefferson Villas), decided on 17 December 2024, the primary issue for determination by Adjudicator Miskinis was whether the body corporate or lot owner was responsible for a waterproofing membrane on a balcony terrace within an exclusive use area.

By-Law

The exclusive use by-law provided:

“The proprietor for the time being of each lot in the building shall be entitled to the exclusive use and enjoyment of part of the common property in the plan in the schedule to this by-law the identifying numbers of which are identical with the number of the lot or lots owned by such proprietor. Each proprietor will use same so as not to create a nuisance.”

Legislation

Given the by-law does not make provision for maintenance and operating costs, section 192(2) of the Body Corporate and Community Management (Standard Module) (Standard Module) makes the owner of the lot responsible for such costs by default.

However, subsection (3) goes on to provide:

“192 Conditions and obligations under exclusive use by-law

…

(3) However, if the lot was created under a building format plan of subdivision, in the absence of other specific provision in the by-law, the owner of the lot is not responsible for:

(a) maintaining in good condition roofing membranes…; or

(b) maintaining in a structurally sound condition any of the following…not constructed by or for the owner:

(i) foundation structures;

(ii) roofing structures providing protection;

(iii) essential supporting framework, including load-bearing walls.”

Arguments

The body corporate, through its lawyers, sought to establish that the balcony terrace was an improvement made by a previous owner of the lot and, accordingly, the lot owner should be responsible for its maintenance – including the waterproofing membrane installed by the previous owner.

The body corporate sought to rely on the improvement provisions of the legislation – specifically, sections 180(3) and 187(4) of the Standard Module, which provide:

“(3)         …the body corporate is not responsible for maintaining fixtures or fittings installed by the occupier of a lot if they were installed for the occupier’s own benefit.”

“187 Improvements to common property by owner of a lot
…
(4) An owner…
…
(b) must maintain the improvement made under the authority in good condition, unless excused by the body corporate.

Grace Lawyers, on behalf of the owner argued that, even if the balcony terrace was a lot owner improvement (which there was some doubt about), the body corporate was responsible for the waterproofing membrane due to the operation of section 192(3)(a) of the Standard Module – given the exclusive use by-law does not make specific provision for the owner to maintain waterproofing membranes.

It was argued on behalf of the lot owner that section 180(3) of the Standard Module has no application, and section 187(4) does not override the default maintenance provisions of section 192(3) of the Standard Module. Reliance was placed on the differential wording of sections 192(3)(a) and (b) of the Standard Module, where the words “not constructed by or for the owner” do not appear in relation to waterproofing membranes.

Outcome

The Adjudicator agreed with the arguments put forward by Grace Lawyers, finding that section 180(3) of the Standard Module had no application (as the balcony terrace was not a ‘fixture or fitting’), and in relation to section 187(4), finding that ‘authorisation of a “lot owner improvement” under section 187 does not override subsection 192(3)(a).’

Accordingly, the Adjudicator found the body corporate was responsible for maintaining the waterproofing membrane, as well as all consequential costs and expenses arising from the waterproofing membrane’s failure.

The failure of the membrane has resulted in significant water ingress and damage to the balcony terrace, and internal areas of the lot. Such damage is not insignificant, and likely to be in the order of $50,000 to $100,000 to repair, so the outcome is of some importance to the lot owner and body corporate.

Analysis

The Jefferson Villas decision highlights the importance of ensuring that exclusive use grants are given under by-laws with appropriate conditions to ensure a body corporate does not unwittingly assume responsibility for maintaining parts of an exclusive use area which might be more fairly lot owner responsibility.

It is notable that the alleged improvement in Jefferson Villas was not the subject of any known body corporate resolution, and not contained in the register of authorisations affecting common property. Accordingly, a question arises whether, if there was a record of the improvement, particularly where there was a condition for the lot owner to maintain waterproofing membranes, the outcome would have been different (notwithstanding the terms of the exclusive use by-law).

Whilst it is possible a different outcome would have resulted, it is certainly not something that bodies corporate should rely upon. On the basis of the Adjudicator’s reasoning in Jefferson Villas, if an exclusive use grant is proposed, it is important for a body corporate to ensure the exclusive use by-law makes specific provision for the owner to maintain waterproofing membranes (if it wishes to make the owner responsible for same).

The same applies to foundation and roofing structures, and essential supporting framework, which are not lot owner improvements. In order to make the owner responsible for such elements, clear provision must be made in the exclusive use by-law for the lot owner to maintain these items.

Similarly, in the event of a lot owner wishing to make an improvement to an existing exclusive use area, the body corporate should insist on an amendment of the exclusive use by-law to make the owner responsible for maintaining waterproofing membranes (if the by-laws do not already do so). The amendment of an exclusive use by-law requires a resolution without dissent.

It is worth noting that the carve outs in section 192 of the Standard Module, imposing responsibility for waterproofing membranes and structural elements in exclusive use areas on bodies corporate, only apply to building format plans. If Jefferson Villas was subdivided by a standard format plan, the outcome would have been different.

Conclusion

The decision of Jefferson Villas is a good reminder that the interplay of legislative provisions in respect of exclusive use areas and common property improvements is a nuanced one, and bodies corporate should take care to ensure they consider the impact and effect of granting exclusive use to a lot owner, or allowing an owner to make changes to common property. In the absence of sound advice, a body corporate may unwittingly assume responsibility for something that it thought would be the responsibility of the owner.

Grace Lawyers has extensive experience and expertise in exclusive use, improvements, and maintenance issues, and can assist committees to ensure that the interests of all lot owners are properly protected when a lot owner is seeking to make a change to common property, or obtain a grant of exclusive use.

 

Written by Jarad Maher, Partner, Grace Lawyers

If you require advice regarding exclusive use areas, improvements, and maintenance issues within your body corporate, please contact our team at Grace Lawyers on 1300 144 436.

Living in Harmony: Navigating Nuisance in NSW Strata Schemes

NSW

As of June 2024, there are approximately 1.2 million people living in strata schemes in NSW and this will likely increase over the coming years. Many people residing in such close proximity will inevitably result in disputes arising from time to time, particularly in terms of nuisance caused by neighbours in a strata scheme.

Oxford Languages Dictionary defines nuisance as “a person or thing causing inconvenience or annoyance”. Within the Strata scheme, this may include but is not limited to issues ranging from excessive noise to offensive odours, nuisance issues can significantly affect the quality of life of strata owners and occupiers. This article aims to provide a brief overview of nuisance and how it may be defined in NSW strata schemes.

Section 153 in Strata Schemes Management Act NSW (SSMA)

While Section 153 of the SSMA does not explicitly define what conduct may constitute “nuisance”, it provides some legislative guidance on how nuisance may be interpreted in NSW strata schemes. The section states that an owner, occupier or someone with a legal interest in a lot in a strata scheme must not use or enjoy:

  1. a lot in a way that causes a nuisance or hazard to any other lot;
  2. the common property in a way that interferes unreasonably with the use or enjoyment of the common property by an occupier of another lot or anyone else that may use and enjoy the common property;
  3. the common property in a way that interferes unreasonably with the use or enjoyment of any other lot or anyone else that may use and enjoy the lot.

In essence, Section 153 of the SSMA prohibits lot owners and occupiers from using or enjoying their lot or common property in a manner that causes, nuisance, hazard or interferes unreasonably with the use or enjoyment of an occupier of the common property or any other lot. This section includes a specific note that smoking may be deemed a nuisance or hazardous, when smoke penetrates a lot or common property.

While this section provides some guidance as to what may constitute nuisance within a strata scheme, we must look to common law for further clarification of the type of conduct that may be deemed actionable nuisance. This is reinforced by the courts where it was noted that the proper test to apply is the ordinary usage of the word:

“It may broadly be said that a useful test is perhaps what is reasonable accordingly to the ordinary usage of mankind living in society, or more correctly in a particular society.” (Sedleigh-Denfield v O’Callahan [1940] AC 80).

Nuisance by way of conduct

In determining the meaning of nuisance, the courts have provided some general principles when nuisance may be established:

  1. A person claiming nuisance owns or has a legal interest in the property;
  2. The alleged offender has interfered with that person’s enjoyment or use of that property; and
  3. The interference was both unreasonable and substantial. (Hargrave v Goldman [1963] HCA 56).

The courts have also indicated a number of aspects that may be considered when determining whether there has been unreasonable interference. A court may take into account the locality in which the interference occurred, the duration, time of day, frequency and extent of the interference and whether there was any malice on the part of the person causing the interference (Dimitrios Michos & Another v Council of the City of Botany Bay [2012] NSWSC 625). It is apparent that the definition of nuisance is not a simple one and will depend on a myriad of factors as to how conduct constituting nuisance can be decided at common law.

Hargrave v Goldman [1963] HCA 56: a case where a lightning strike ignited a tree, the owner had taken steps to cut down and prevent the fire from spreading but after leaving the fire unattended, the fire spread to a neighbouring land, causing significant damage.

In this case, the court defined “nuisance” as an “unlawful interference with a person’s use or enjoyment of land, or of some right over, or in connexion with it”. He also noted the significance of the phrase “unlawful interference” and defined the term “nuisance” generally as being a “state of affairs that is either continuous or recurrent”.

The Owners Strata Plan No 2245 v Veney [2020] NSWSC 134: a case where a lot owner was given exclusive use of a part of common property for parking his vehicle, which resulted in the parking spaces of other lot owners being difficult to access.

Here, the court provided some clarity on the definition of nuisance whereby:

  1. “The mere causing of some inconvenience is not necessarily an actionable nuisance”; and
  2. “In broad terms, an actionable nuisance can be described as unlawful interference with a person’s use or enjoyment of land. Liability founded upon a state of affairs created, adopted or continued by a person, otherwise than the reasonable and convenient use of the person’s own land which, to a substantial degree, harms another owner or occupier of the land in the enjoyment of that person’s land.”

Vincent v Peacock [1973] 1 NSWLRS 466: a case where a person was engaging in whistling, shouting, singing and using unseemly words whilst inside their own property. The court found that the person’s conduct amounted to nuisance and affected other people’s use and enjoyment of their own property nearby.

Conclusion

Nuisance may be a significant issue in strata schemes, creating tension between residents and impacting on the quality of life in these communities. However, it is important to distinguish between conduct that is no more than mere inconvenience and conduct that amounts to actionable nuisance. While inconveniences are inevitable in strata schemes, not every inconvenience can be deemed actionable nuisance.

 

Written by Anna Hahm, Partner and Ronald Mak, Associate, Grace Lawyers

 

If you need guidance on managing nuisances in your strata schemes, contact our Sydney team at Grace Lawyers on 1300 144 436.

 

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should obtain independent legal advice on their specific legal issues.

Recent Termination of Management Rights—What Went Wrong?

QLD

In October 2024 in Linali Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Crown CTS 41282 [2024] QCAT 446, Member Lumb of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal ordered the Body corporate to pay the Caretaker $311,958 by January 2025 because the Body Corporate improperly terminated a Caretaking Agreement and Letting Agreement.

Critical mistakes were made and key lessons must be learned. It’s essential for bodies corporate to adopt these insights to prevent a similar outcome.

Background

The Caretaker entered into a Caretaking Agreement and Letting Agreement with the Body corporate by Deed of Assignment made in October 2018.

The Body corporate gave remedial action notices to the Caretaker dated in May 2021 and September 2021. It is not known what allegations were made in the May Notice, however it seems to be matters surrounding the performance of duties relating to common property. The September notice alleged a failure to carry out various duties including aerating garden beds, cleaning fire sprinkler pipework, conferring with the Committee’s nominated representative, keeping common property in good order and repair, carrying out reasonable directions, and supervising contractors.

On 2 November 2021, the Body corporate resolved at a general meeting to terminate the Caretaking Agreement. A notice was sent to the Caretaker terminating the Caretaking Agreement in reliance on that resolution. As part of the termination, the Body corporate did not permit the Caretaker to access the Caretaker’s office at the scheme.

On 12 January 2022, the Caretaker asserted that termination of the Caretaking Agreement by the Body corporate was unlawful and, as a result, the Caretaker elected to terminate the Caretaking Agreement.

On 17 March 2023, the Caretaker also elected to terminate the Letting Agreement based on the Body corporate’s refusal to allow the Caretaker to access the office.

The Caretaker alleged the May and September Notice were both invalid, the Body corporate’s resolution to terminate the Caretaking Agreement was unreasonably made, the Body corporate was in breach of the Letting Agreement, and that the Body corporate should pay damages to the Caretaker as a result.

Were the remedial action notices invalid?

Member Lumb determined the May notice was invalid because it did not state, as required by the regulation module, that the Body corporate may terminate the Caretaking Agreement if the Caretaker did not comply with the May notice.

The reasons for this included:

  1. the intent of the regulation module is to put a person on notice that a failure to comply with a notice may result in the relevant agreement being brought to an end;
  2. while the precise words of the regulation module need not be stated in the notice, the words that are stated must have the effect of putting the person on express notice that the relevant agreement may come to an end;
  3. the Body corporate generally reserving its rights (one of those rights being the right to terminate the relevant agreement based on a failure to comply with the notice) was not enough to comply with the requirements of the regulation module.

Member Lumb determined that the September notice was invalid because 34 of the 37 breaches identified by that notice did not provide a basis for termination.

The reasons for this included:

  1. the Body corporate did not press 31 of the 37 alleged breaches at the hearing;
  2. of the six alleged breaches that were pressed:

a. three alleged breaches were upheld, being:

(i) the Caretaker failed to aerate the garden beds monthly;

(ii) the Caretaker did not clean the fire sprinkler pipework in the basement monthly;

(iii) the Caretaker made a conscious choice to confer only with the Body corporate manager not the Committee’s representative;

b. three alleged breaches were not upheld, being:

(i) the changing of the locks on the Caretaker’s office door did not constitute a failure to keep the common property in good order and repair;

(ii) not removing the A4 piece of paper affixed with sticky tape to a camera in the Caretaker’s office as requested by a direction given by the Committee did not constitute a failure to carry out reasonable directions because the direction itself was not reasonable;

(iii) an allegation that the Caretaker did not supervise contractors engaged in work on the common property because there was no detail provided about when that occurred or what supervision required.

Did the Body corporate act reasonably in resolving the motion to terminate the Caretaking Agreement?

The motion resolved by the Body corporate to terminate the Caretaking Agreement was based on an alleged failure by the Caretaker to comply with the May and September notices.

Member Lumb determined that the:

  1. resolution on 2 November 2021 was invalid because the resolution was based on an invalid May notice and no termination right had arisen based on the September notice because the September notice had not yet been given to the Caretaker;
  2. resolution on the motion to terminate a caretaking or letting agreement is subject to the Body corporate’s duty to act reasonably; and
  3. Body corporate acted unreasonably in resolving that motion because:

(a) there was no valid remedial action notice in existence at the time of the resolution or any failure to comply with such a valid notice (as the May notice was invalid and the September notice had not yet been given to the Caretaker). There were no circumstances existing at the time of the resolution justifying termination;

(b) the resolution purported to delegate the decision to terminate the Caretaking Agreement to the Committee, but the decision to terminate such an agreement is a restricted issue for the Committee.

Did the Body corporate breach the Letting Agreement?

Member Lumb determined that by the Body corporate refusing the Caretaker access to the office, thereby not allowing the Caretaker to operate the letting business, the Body corporate committed a substantial breach of the Letting Agreement.

This is because access to the Caretaker’s office was so fundamental to the Letting Agreement and the operation of the letting business, and not allowing such access breached the implied term of cooperation.

What damages was the Body corporate ordered to pay?

By purporting to terminate the Caretaking Agreement when it was not entitled to do so, and in breaching the Letting Agreement, the Body corporate’s conduct amounted to a renunciation or repudiation of both agreements.

Ironically, this entitled the Caretaker to terminate the Caretaking Agreement and Letting Agreement (which it did) and seek damages.

Member Lumb was empowered to order damages to the extent that it would place the Caretaker in the same position as if the agreements had been performed. Experts calculated damages for both parties based on loss of future profits.

Experts gave evidence for the Body corporate and Caretaker about the various expenses, discount rates and approaches that should be taken to arrive at the appropriate assessment of damages.

After considering the experts’ evidence, Member Lumb ordered the Body corporate to pay the Caretaker $311,958.

The usual rule in the Tribunal is that each party bears its own costs. However, the Caretaker sought that the Body corporate pay its costs of the proceeding. The Tribunal considered it appropriate to do so and ordered the Body corporate to pay 85% of the Caretaker’s costs on the District Court scale. This will require a cost assessment process to occur and is likely to result in the Body corporate paying a significant amount of money to the Caretaker for costs.

So, what went wrong?

This case serves as a critical reminder of the following:

  1. despite the terms of an engagement or authorisation, where a purported ground of termination falls within the scope of the regulation modules, the requirements of that regulation module must be followed in order to validly terminate the engagement or authorisation;
  2. a remedial action notice must strictly comply with the regulation modules otherwise it will likely be invalid and any resolution relying on that notice will also be invalid;
  3. a Body corporate’s resolution on a motion to terminate a caretaking or letting agreement is subject to the duty to act reasonably;
  4. a termination motion should only be considered at a general meeting if a right of termination has arisen based on a failure to comply with a valid remedial action notice and must not delegate that decision to the Committee;
  5. the nature and number of any unremedied breaches following the giving of a remedial action notice is an important factor that influences whether a decision to terminate is made reasonably.

Summary

In Linali Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Crown CTS 41282, the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal decided that the Body corporate improperly terminated the Caretaking and Letting Agreements, ordering them to pay $311,958 in damages. The tribunal found the Body corporate’s remedial action notices were invalid and that their resolution to terminate was unreasonable, as it relied on invalid notices and delegated the decision to the Committee. Additionally, the Body corporate’s refusal to grant the Caretaker access to the office breached the Letting Agreement. The case highlights the importance of strict compliance with the regulation modules and the duty to act reasonably in termination decisions.

 

Written by Brendan Pitman, Partner, Grace Lawyers

 

If you are considering performance management options for a caretaker and require legal guidance contact our Queensland team at Grace Lawyers on 1300 144 436. 

 

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should obtain independent legal advice on their specific legal issues.

NSW Supreme Court Rules in Favour of OC for Unapproved Works to Common Property

NSW

20 February 2025: Colman v The Owners – Strata Plan 61131 [2025] NSWSC 63.

Grace Lawyers was recently successful in the NSW Supreme Court in defending an owners corporation against a large claim made by a lot owner for unauthorised common property works. In deciding in favour of the owners corporation, the Court clarified how the various maintenance, approval and compensation provisions worked together under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW).

The issues that were decided in the owners corporation’s favour were:

  • A lot owner cannot recover as damages (either prospectively or retrospectively) under Section 106(5) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) the cost of common property works undertaken without the approval of the owners corporation or an order of the Tribunal;
  • Generally speaking, an owners corporation is not to be taken to have refused an application for approval to carry out common property works without having first considered it by motion at a general meeting (or strata committee meeting where appropriate);
  • The Tribunal is not empowered to make an order approving common property works without those works first having been considered and refused by an owners corporation at the appropriate meeting.

The owners corporation had originally arranged for repairs to be carried out by a contractor to address a water leak emanating from a rooftop terrace. Without approval of the owners corporation, the lot owner made separate arrangements with the contractor to renovate the terrace area (including carrying out further common property works) and then sought to recover the substantial cost from the owners corporation as damages under Section 106(5) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW). The lot owner argued that the required common property rectification works were more extensive than what the owners corporation had originally arranged and so he should be entitled to recover the cost of that work as well as lot property “repairs”.

Before commencing proceedings, the lot owner submitted an incomplete building application to retrospectively approve the renovation works at strata committee level. That application was refused on the basis that the strata committee did not have the power to approve the work (the work could not be classified as minor renovations). Subsequently, during the proceedings, the lot owner argued that an existing common property by-law in respect to other roofing works should be extended to apply to his rooftop terrace works.

The Tribunal initially dismissed the claim on the basis it was not satisfied that the waterproofing and tiling works claimed as compensation were for the purpose of rectifying a defect in the common property rather than forming part of the lot owner’s planned terrace renovation works. Accordingly, the cost of the renovation works (including the common property works) could not be awarded as “damages” under Section 106(5) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW). The Tribunal also found that it could not make an order retrospectively approving the works under section 126(2) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) on the basis that an owners corporation must first refuse consent before the Tribunal could make such an order. Finally, the existing common property rights by-law did not apply as it was not passed for the purposes of the lot owner’s renovation works. The Tribunal’s decision was confirmed on appeal to the Appeal Panel.

On further appeal to the NSW Supreme Court, the Justice confirmed the correctness of the earlier decisions and made additional findings as follows:

  • Where approval has been sought by way of special resolution and a common property rights by-law, an application for unreasonable refusal can be made under Section 149 (in respect to the common property rights by-law) and Section 126(2) (in respect to approval of the common property work);
  • An owners corporation can undertake repairs to common property without needing to have passed an ordinary or special resolution. An owners corporation can also authorise a lot owner to carry out such repair works via the same process;
  • Retrospective approval can be given to common property works by an owners corporation (under Sections 108, 110, and, where appropriate, 106) and the Tribunal under Section 126(2);
  • The Tribunal is not authorised to make an order permitting common property works under Section 126(2) unless approval had first been sought from the owners corporation (and refused);
  • For repairs to common property, this refusal of consent commonly takes the form of the owners corporation not passing a special resolution for the works at a general meeting, but in certain circumstances, an owners corporation could be found to have acted in a way that constitutes a constructive refusal of consent, even though it has not made a formal decision to refuse to approve the works at a general meeting.
  • Damage/compensation cannot be awarded under Section 106(5) for common property works that had not been approved in the required manner (retrospectively or prospectively).

This decision highlights the crucial role of an owners corporation in controlling and approving works on common property and that lot owners cannot circumvent the process by carrying out works without approval and then seeking to recover the cost of carrying out the work later as “damages” under Section 106(5) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW). It is also part of a number of recent NSW Supreme Court decisions defining the limits of damages claims under Section 106(5), and that such claims are not a “blank cheque” against an owners corporation.

 

Written by Peter Ton, Partner, and Andrew Stojanovic, Senior Associate, Grace Lawyers

 

If you require guidance in relation to unauthorised common property works, contact our NSW team at Grace Lawyers on 1300 144 436.

 

 

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should obtain independent legal advice on their specific legal issues.

Choosing the Best Contract for Body Corporate Renovations and Repairs

QLD

When a body corporate undertakes renovation or repair work, selecting the right building contract is crucial to managing risks, ensuring compliance and protecting the interests of lot owners. Most of the contracts used in residential building projects are standard form contracts, such as those published by Australian Standards (e.g., AS 4000, AS 4902), the Master Builders Association (MBA) and the Housing Industry Association (HIA). While these contracts provide a useful framework, they are not tailored to body corporate projects and often require amendments to properly allocate risk and responsibilities.

Why standard form contracts matter

Standard form contracts attempt to achieve a balance between the interests of principals (such as a body corporate) and contractors. However, they are designed for general construction projects and may not account for the unique considerations of body corporate works, such as common property obligations, funding approvals and strata-specific legal requirements. Failing to select and amend an appropriate contract can expose the body corporate to unnecessary risks, disputes and financial losses.

Key considerations when selecting a contract

1. Project scope and complexity

  • Minor Repairs and Maintenance: Smaller-scale work, such as routine maintenance or minor repairs, may be covered under Minor Works, MBA or HIA contracts.
  • Major Renovations and Structural Work: More comprehensive contracts like AS 4000 (construct-only) or AS 4902 (design and construct) may be appropriate for larger projects.

2. Risk allocation

Construction contracts allocate risks such as delays, cost variations and defects. Without careful amendments, a body corporate could bear excessive risks, particularly in:

  • Extensions of time and delay damages
  • Defective work liability
  • Insurance and indemnities
  • Dispute resolution processes

3. Compliance with Laws and Regulations

Most standard contracts do not reflect current legislation, such as:

  • Security of Payment Laws – Ensuring that payment terms align with statutory requirements of approval processes.
  • Workplace Health & Safety – Addressing responsibilities for common property.
  • GST and PPSA Laws – Ensuring proper risk apportionment and security.

Managing access requirements to avoid delays

For projects involving common property or exclusive-use areas, it is critical to manage access requirements effectively to prevent unnecessary delays and additional costs. Under section 163 of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), notices must be provided to lot owners before access is granted. Standard form contracts often do not account for this requirement, meaning amendments may be necessary to clarify the contractor’s obligations in scheduling work around occupiers and ensuring proper notice is given.

Without careful planning, contractors may face delays in accessing work areas, leading to claims for extensions of time and additional costs. Contracts should include provisions requiring contractors to coordinate with the body corporate and provide advanced work schedules to facilitate smooth access arrangements.

Why early contract reviews are essential

Reviewing and amending contracts before they are signed helps bodies corporate:

  1. Identify and mitigate key risks – Many standard contracts shift risk onto the party least able to manage it.
  2. Ensure compliance with legal requirements – Standard contracts may not reflect recent legislative changes.
  3. Simplify contract administration – Tailoring contracts to body corporate needs can reduce administrative burdens and streamline project management.

How we can help

Our construction law team assists bodies corporate with:

  • Selecting the most appropriate contract for renovation and repair projects.
  • Reviewing and amending standard form contracts to align with body corporate requirements.
  • Ensuring compliance with Queensland building laws and strata legislation.
  • Advising on contract administration and dispute resolution.

Engaging an experienced construction lawyer early in the process ensures that the contract properly protects the body corporate’s interests, minimises risks and promotes smooth project execution.

 

Written by Peter Waller, Special Counsel – QLS Accredited Specialist – Commercial Litigation and Brendan Pitman, Partner, Grace Lawyers

 

To discuss how we can assist with your next renovation or repair project, contact our Special Counsel, Peter Waller on 1300 144 436.

 

 

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should obtain independent legal advice on their specific legal issues.